Best Bourbon for Old Fashioned Cocktails: The Ultimate Guide
Best bourbon for old fashioned cocktails – If you’re a bourbon fan, the Old Fashioned is likely already on your radar.
With its simple yet sophisticated blend of whiskey, bitters, sugar, and a twist of citrus, this drink has stood the test of time for good reason.
Before moving to Kentucky nine years ago, this drink wasn’t really on my radar. Now it’s all around me at parties and dinners. It’s my husband’s go to for special occasion outings.
This drink, along with the Mint Julep of course, is a staple at Kentucky Derby parties as well as Churchill Downs itself.
In this post, we’ll dive into what makes the best Old Fashioned and share some tips for crafting the perfect one for your taste.
Cheers to the timeless charm of this iconic drink!
Photo: Philip Sukhenko
Best Bourbon for Old Fashioned Cocktails- what is an Old Fashioned?
Definition and History
- The bourbon serves as the foundation of the cocktail, adding unique characteristics and complexity to the drink.
- It’s a simple yet sophisticated drink consisting of bourbon, sugar, bitters, and a twist of citrus peel.
- An Old Fashioned is a classic cocktail that dates back to the early 19th century.
Essential Ingredients
- Bourbon whiskey is the primary spirit used in modern Old Fashioneds.
- Sugar, bitters, and a twist of citrus peel are the other essential ingredients.
- The quality of the ingredients is crucial in creating a delicious Old Fashioned.
Photo: Jessica Kantak Bailey
Understanding Bourbon Whiskey
Types of Bourbon
- There are several types of bourbon, including straight bourbon, blended bourbon, and single-barrel bourbon.
- Each type has its unique characteristics and flavor profile.
Age and Maturation
- Age is a critical factor in determining the flavor profile of bourbon.
- Generally speaking, older bourbons tend to have more depth of flavor and complexity because of the extended aging process.
Mash Bill and Flavor Profile
- The mash bill, or the combination of grains used in the bourbon’s production, also plays a significant role in the flavor.
- Bourbons with a higher percentage of corn in the mash bill tend to have a sweeter taste, which can complement the other ingredients in an Old Fashioned.
Photo: Adam Jaime
Photo: Katherine Conrad
Top Bourbon Recommendations for Old Fashioned Cocktails
Budget-Friendly Options
- Bulleit Bourbon is a high-rye bourbon with spicy notes of cinnamon and pepper, perfect for adding complexity to an Old Fashioned.
- Old Grand Dad Bottled in Bond is a value-priced bourbon with a distinct roasted hazelnut character and flavor notes of butterscotch, caramel, and baking spice.
Mid-Range Options
- Four Roses Single Barrel is a well-crafted bourbon that is perfect for an Old Fashioned.
- Woodford Reserve is a versatile bourbon that shines in an Old Fashioned. A keen nose will smell dried fruit, vanilla, and caramel, with a hint of spice.
Luxury Options
- Blanton’s Single Barrel has a complex flavor profile with tones of caramel, vanilla, and spice, making it an ideal bourbon for an Old Fashioned with depth.
- Eagle Rare is a 10-year-old bourbon with a rich, toasty flavor profile and a hint of wood tannin, perfect for an Old Fashioned.
Photo: Alaksiej Carankievic
Exploring Other Notable Bourbons
Wild Turkey 101
- Wild Turkey 101 boasts a high proof and bold flavor. You’ll notice caramel, spice, and oak that shine in an Old Fashioned.
- It has a smooth, velvety texture with a long, lingering finish, perfect for sipping slowly and savoring the rich flavors of this cocktail.
Wild Turkey Rare Breed
- Wild Turkey Rare Breed includes scents of Spring flowers, a touch of black pepper, and almonds mixed with layers of honey and dates.
- It has warm and smokey flavors of grain and spice, finishing long and lingering with spicy tone.
Buffalo Trace Stagg Jr
- Buffalo Trace Stagg Jr offers rich, sweet, chocolate, and brown sugar flavors that mingle in perfect balance with bold rye spiciness.
- It finishes with hints of cherries, cloves, and smokiness.
Maker’s Mark Cask Strength
- Maker’s Mark Cask Strength has an aroma of big oak, vanilla, and caramel.
- It has a robust, warm texture with notes of caramel, vanilla, and spice, finishing long on the front of the tongue, harmonious with no harsh bitterness.
Photo: Alan Francis
Crafting the Perfect Old Fashioned Cocktail
Recipe Variations and Tips
- The best bourbon for an Old Fashioned cocktail is one that is 100 proof or higher.
- Combine simple syrup and 2 dashes of bitters in an old-fashioned glass.
- Fill with ice, stir, and garnish with an orange peel and maraschino cherry.
Sugar Cube vs. Granulated Sugar
- Sugar cubes take longer to dissolve, while granulated sugar dissolves more quickly.
- Choose the method that works best for you.
Using Flavored Bitters
- Yes, you can experiment with different flavored bitters to add your own twist.
- Adjust the amount according to the potency of the flavor.
Photo: Drew Beamer
The Role of Proof and ABV in Old Fashioned Cocktails
Understanding Proof and ABV
- Proof is a measure of the bourbon’s strength, with higher proof bourbons having a more intense flavor.
- ABV (alcohol by volume) is a measure of the bourbon’s alcohol content.
How Proof Affects the Flavor
- Higher proof bourbons tend to have a more intense flavor, while lower proof bourbons are smoother and more approachable.
Photo: Woody Kelly
Finding the Best Bourbon for an Old Fashioned
Balance and Complexity
- The ideal bourbon for an Old Fashioned should be rich, rounded, and bold in flavor.
- Look for bourbons with a balance of sweet, spicy, and fruity notes.
Classic Bourbon Flavor Profile
- A classic bourbon flavor profile includes notes of caramel, vanilla, and oak.
- Look for bourbons with a smooth, velvety texture and a long, satisfying finish.
Photo: Nuff
Serving and Pairing Ideas for Old Fashioned Cocktails
Classic Pairings
- Serve Old Fashioned cocktails at a party with festive entertaining in mind.
- Pair with appetizers like cheese and charcuterie, nuts, or popcorn.
Modern Twists
- Experiment with different ingredients and flavor combinations to create unique Old Fashioned recipes.
- Try pairing Old Fashioned cocktails with modern twists, such as chocolate-covered cherries or citrus-infused simple syrup.
Photo: Jakub Dziubak
Experimenting with New Recipes and Bourbons
Tips for Batch-Making
- Yes, you can make a large batch of Old Fashioned cocktails in advance and add ice to individual glasses when serving.
- This ensures that each guest can enjoy a well-chilled and perfectly balanced Old Fashioned.
How to Store and Serve
- Store bourbon in a cool, dark place to preserve its flavor and aroma.
- Serve Old Fashioned cocktails in a rocks glass with a large ice cube to prevent dilution.
Photo: Sean Bernstein
Pin This Post and Save it For Later
FAQs
What’s the origin of the Old Fashioned cocktail?
The Old Fashioned cocktail dates back to the early 19th century, originally known as a “whiskey cocktail.” It got more popular as bartenders started adding bitters, sugar, and a twist of citrus, resulting in the Old Fashioned we know today.
2. What are the main ingredients in an Old Fashioned?
An Old Fashioned typically includes whiskey (often bourbon or rye), bitters, sugar (or a sugar cube), a twist of citrus peel (usually orange or lemon), and sometimes a maraschino cherry for garnish.
3. Should I use bourbon or rye for an Old Fashioned?
Both bourbon and rye whiskey work well in an Old Fashioned, but the choice comes down to personal preference. Bourbon tends to be sweeter and richer, while rye offers a spicier, more robust flavor.
4. Can I make an Old Fashioned without bitters?
Bitters are an essential component of an Old Fashioned, as they balance the sweetness and add depth to the flavor. While you can technically make the drink without bitters, it won’t have the same iconic taste.
5. How do you properly garnish an Old Fashioned?
The traditional garnish for an Old Fashioned is a twist of orange peel. Some people also add a maraschino cherry, but purists often stick with just the citrus peel for something simple.
6. Why is the Old Fashioned considered a “timeless” cocktail?
The Old Fashioned has remained popular for over a century because of its simplicity, balance, and versatility. It’s a drink that appeals to both whiskey lovers and those who appreciate a well-crafted, classic cocktail.
Photo: Misunderstood Whiskey
Final Thoughts on the Best Bourbons for Old Fashioned Cocktails
Finding Your Favorite Bourbon
There’s something special about an Old Fashioned – its simplicity, balance, and rich history make it a cocktail that never goes out of style.
Whether you prefer it with bourbon or rye, with a twist of orange or a cherry garnish, making the perfect Old Fashioned is all about finding the right balance for your taste.
So next time you’re in the mood for a classic drink, reach for the ingredients and enjoy the timeless appeal of the Old Fashioned.
Don’t be afraid to experiment with this fun drink especially if you’re hosting a party and want to go all in on the Kentucky Derby food.
And if you want ideas for Kentucky Derby dresses or hats, you’re in luck because I’ve got posts on those as well!
So whether you’ve got a cozy night in or are actually headed to Churchill Downs in Kentucky, here’s to sipping on something truly unforgettable!
Photo: Josh Collesano
Hi I’m Erica! TV news anchor and mom to 4 littles. I’m obsessed with creating those “wow” moments in life through crafting at home, cool travel adventures and special celebrations with loved ones. Thanks for joining me on this adventure!
